The Islanders have defeated the Capitals after a late-game surge, coming back from a 2-0 deficit to score four unanswered goals. After the two teams’ bad blood being evidenced by the hard-hitting game throughout, will the Islanders be able to repeat their dominance before and after the whistle? Here’s what our writers have to say about the rest of the series.

Shawn D’Aversa: Islanders 4-2 Capitals

Besides the penalty troubles, the Islanders played a very convincing Game 1. They were the dominant team five-on-five, got stellar goaltending from Semyon Varlamov, and have continued to get contributions from all across their lineup. When the Islanders are hot, they are hot. And right now they are rolling. If they can stay out of the penalty box, the Isles should be able to win at least three out of the next five games. The Capitals will definitely respond with a vengeance, and there is a good chance they’ll grab Game 2, but as long as the Islanders continue their style of play and determination, they should take it.

Will Wiegelman: Islanders 4-3 Capitals

That game was demoralizing for the Caps. Brayden Holtby was awful and Washington looked terrible in the 3rd period. Lee’s controversial hit on Backstrom seems to have rattled them. Tom Wilson will be easy bait for bad penalties for the rest of the series. Washington scored 2 power play goals in game 1, proving the need for the Isles to stay out of the box.

Matthew Page: Islanders 4-3 Capitals

The Islanders took the game away from Washington after falling behind 2-0. The Capitals will have a lot to play for in order to avoid falling down two games in the series, and they will be without Nicklas Backstrom for the game. However, I think Todd Reirden got his message across, and someone will step up in Backstrom’s absence to even the series.

David Lazar: Islanders 4-3 Capitals

The Islanders found a way to win in Game 1. It is a very good sign that they won a game where they took seven penalties and did not play their best hockey for 39 minutes. The penalty kill was decent besides two fluke goals. The offense looked great., and during five-on-five play the Islanders dominated. With a performance like that behind them, New York has to be favored in this series, but Washington will put up a fight. I think the Capitals will win Game 2, but the Islanders will win the series.

Aidan Resnick: Islanders 4-2 Capitals

Winning a playoff series is difficult, but winning a playoff series without your starting goaltender is a much tougher task. The loss of Ilya Samsonov and the consequent reliance on Braden Holtby presents a weakness, as Samsonov’s production was above replacement-level this season, while Holtby’s production was far below replacement-level this season. Since Barry Trotz took over, the Islanders have portrayed an elite defensive structure with offensive upside; although the Islanders’ offense may struggle at times, they likely will look to exploit the goaltending weakness of the Capitals. Ultimately, despite the Capitals’ offensive potential at any given moment, their defense and goaltending will make far too many mistakes on which the Islanders could capitalize, advancing the Islanders to the second round of the Stanley Cup Playoffs.

Ethan Halle: Islanders 4-3 Capitals

The Islanders are fully healthy and dangerous. They have the right structure to potentially take them far. Throughout the round robin, the Capitals struggled a bit; Lars Eller is out for game 1 and John Carlson is a game time decision. The Islanders’ style of play is perfect to counter the offense of the Capitals.

Leave comment